Sarah and Trevor's day had us hooked from the first speech to the last dance. The weekend kicked off with a rehearsal dinner packed with emotional, hilarious, tell-all stories from their closest people… capped off by a perfect sunset and an actual surprise rainbow, like the sky decided to get in on the celebration.

The next day, they got dressed in the Pridwin's cabins and later, said their vows by the water. After cocktail hour, everyone headed inside to The Pridwin’s iconic bar and cozy lounge. Bookcase, vintage details, Martha-Stewart-approved charm and all. The design, the fall colors, the easy energy… everything just worked. Once the dancing started, the place turned into the best kind of chaos. 

Some weddings just hit different—and this one took place at the Martha-Stewart-approved hotel: The Pridwin on Shelter Island.